Logo Kingdom of the Netherlands
 

Tolerance and Tension: New York and Amsterdam in the 17th Century

Johannes Lingelbach, View of Dam Square with the New City Hall Under Construction [De Dam, gezien naar het Noorden, met het Stadhuis in aanbouw], 1656. From the Collection of the Amsterdam Museum. A lively historical city square scene with people and buildings under a cloudy sky showcases daily life in Amsterdam, capturing the essence of a vibrant community.
Johannes Lingelbach, "View of Dam Square with the New City Hall Under Construction", 1656. From the Collection of the Amsterdam Museum
Supported by: Dutch Culture
Future400

The symposium "Tolerance and Tension: New York and Amsterdam in the 17th Century" brings together leading scholars, thinkers, and artists for a day of discovery and debate about questions of pluralism, migration, and the fragile promise of liberty in Amsterdam and New Amsterdam.

This year marks a noteworthy convergence: the 400th anniversary of New Amsterdam, the city that became New York, and the 750th anniversary of Amsterdam’s founding. These milestones offer an opportunity to reflect on two cities that helped shape our modern ideas of toleration, diversity, and freedom of conscience, while also pondering the limits and contradictions of those ideals.

The symposium “Tolerance and Tension” brings three provocative panels, a keynote from world-renowned Spinoza scholar Steven Nadler, and a slate of live performances, the symposium explores questions of pluralism, migration, and the fragile promise of liberty that are pressingly relevant today.

Get your tickets here.

Presented in collaboration with the New Netherland Institute, and with the generous support of the FUTURE 400 Program of the Consulate-General of the Netherlands in New York, and the Rockefeller Brothers Fund.

Program Details

9–9:08 am: Welcome, Russell Shorto, Director, New Amsterdam Project at The New York Historical

9:08–9:15 am: Welcome, Dewi van de Weerd, Ambassador for International Cultural Cooperation, Kingdom of the Netherlands

9:15–10:30 am: Panel 1: “Diversity and Toleration in the Netherlands”
The Dutch Republic was famed for tolerance. Where did it come from, and what were its limits?

Speakers include Benjamin Kaplan of the University College London, Mark Ponte of the City Archives Amsterdam, and Susanah Romney of New York University. Moderated by Deborah Hamer, Executive Director, New Netherland Institute.

10:30-11 am: Break

11 am – 12:15 pm: Panel 2: “Diversity and Toleration in New Netherland”
New Netherland’s population was unusually diverse compared to other North American colonies. But how well did the famed “liberty of conscience” of the home country carry across the ocean?

Speakers include Evan Haefeli of Texas A&M University, Rachel Talbert of Columbia University, and Alan Mikhail of Yale University. Moderated by Russell Shorto, Director, New Amsterdam Project.

12:15–2 pm: Lunch

2:00–3:15 pm: Panel 3: “New Netherland Migrations”
Dreamers, traders, refugees, and the enslaved – who came to New Netherland? And who was forcibly brought there? What circumstances drove them to create one of the most diverse settlements in North America?

Speakers include Dagomar Degroot of Georgetown University, independent scholar Lavada Nahon, and Chelsea Teale of the New Netherland Research Center. Moderated by Jaap Jacobs, Honorary Research Fellow, University of St. Andrews.

3:15–3:30 pm: Break

3:30-4:15 pm: Keynote Address: Steven Nadler, William H. Hay II Professor of Philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison

“Spinoza and Toleration”: Spinoza is one of history’s greatest proponents of political and religious toleration, whose once-scandalous views anticipate the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. As he says at the end of his Theological-Political Treatise (1670), “everyone should be free to think what he wants and say what he thinks.” But do we dare take Spinoza at his word? Should there be limits to free expression? Who would set them?

4:15-4:30 pm: Break

4:30–5:30 pm: FUTURE 400 Closing

We close the day with a slate of dynamic talks and showcases, looking back on the FUTURE400 cultural program marking the history of Lenapehoking, the arrival of Dutch settlers 400 years ago, and all that ensued, good and bad, creating the place we now call New York. Participating are the Lenape Center, Culture Commissioner Laurie Cumbo, and FUTURE 400 partners Battery Dance, Henry Street Settlement with Ramblers Studio New York, and the National Black Theater—artists whose work channels the diversity and creative fusion that have defined New York since its earliest days.

5:30–7 pm: Reception

Supported by: Dutch Culture
Future400

Event details

Date

Sat, 15 Nov - Sat, 15 Nov 2025

Location

New York Historical, New York

All Events in New York

Categories
  • Heritage  
  • Heritage  
 

Sat, 15 Nov - Sat, 15 Nov 2025

New York Historical

170 Central Prk W. | New York

"Tolerance and Tension: New York and Amsterdam in the 17th Century"
Visit Event page >